tenet can't hear dialogue reddit

Christopher Nolan’s brain-scrambling sci-fi thriller Tenet is getting an earful from fans who can’t hear properly the movie’s dialogue.. Maybe some people are complaining about that scene, but I wanted so bad to not believe the sound issues I had heard about and there was a scene where two characters are talking outside (not in a busy location) and I couldn’t hear it. I wish I could have been a fly on the wall in the editing suite where he was discussing these choices with his sound mixer. He may be wrong but it's how he sees himself. I thought the concept was explained fairly early on. I thought people were overblowing the can’t hear dialog issue but wow this was bad and it wasn’t just that the music was mixed too loud. It has been rather well-documented online about how many who saw the film theatrically had a hard time hearing the dialogue in the film, yet Nolan has insisted it is all intentional as part of the “sonic experience.” I saw it in the theater, so there were no subtitles. I literally laughed at that part. I enjoyed the movie, but that line was so bad. I want the movie to succeed! ", "You fight for a cause you barely understand, with people you trust so little you've told them nothing. Possibly because you couldn’t hear important dialogue, ... the film lives on in Reddit … I really had to strain over half the time to understand what anybody was saying. I also realized I had never seen a film with a scene on a moving hydrofoil, apparently it’s hard to pull off especially with imax. Just my opinion. If that's the approach in a movie - fair enough, great idea. I will never get tired of Tom Hardy roasting Joseph Gordon-Levitt! Some people write dialogue that doesn't make sense no matter how clearly you can hear it, how is unintelligible dialogue any different? All over this subreddit and elsewhere people claim that some dialogues in this movie are 'bad'. So what are the examples? You're a fanatic. I mean, I get where he's coming from wanting to try artistic sound design in film, but it just doesn't work well with his stories (well, maybe other than Dunkirk). Where are the movies out there that make chunks of dialogue impossible to hear and somehow that's seen as an artistic choice? I don't know if you'd describe me as a Christopher Nolan fangirl (although you certainly could), but it was one of the movies I was most anticipating this year (number one was Dune). It almost seemed to me like Nolan was trying to confuse the audience through the unintelligible dialogue to make the plot seem smarter than it really is. That said, I don't recall any specific examples of "poor dialogue." Another Reddit user notes, "I couldn't hear a solid 30 minutes of dialogue because everyone was mumbling through masks." No mate, you're not Bergman, shut the fuck up and accept the plainly justified criticism. This is simply not the case with Tenet, and I think it's a clear case of a director not having anybody (smart) around to tell him "no." It would be nice if we could hear the dialogue. no loud noises making it difficult for the characters to be heard in-universe). Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I think it's just a bad choice. This is absolutely hilarious to me. I mean, it doesn't look as though he's got a creative team that has valuable input for him), PS: Thank you for the awards, y'all, just doing my part. That’s why I’m guessing most people aren’t complaining about that one, but you never know. Audiences who have seen Tenet are complaining that crucial dialogue is unintelligible due to the bad sound mixing on Christopher Nolan's blockbuster. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. If Nolan wants to experiment he can, doesn't really matter whether 1% or 99% of people hate the experiment or not. ... couldn’t hear dialogue half the time. Getting impressionistic with music and cinematography - even acting - I get. Now, if the point IS TO IRRITATE me, like the movie is trying to make a point with that - sure. The biggest subreddit dedicated to Christopher Nolan's Tenet. Tenet Faces Backlash Over Its Sound Mix, Some Fans Think Its Awful. It’s not just the music that’s too loud over the dialogue, there’s a scene on a small boat on the water and you can’t hear the dialogue over the water. What really bothers me about that quote is that more than half of the dialogue in Tenet is exposition. The scene you’re describing sounds like it was intentional. The whole damn movie it's impossible to hear what anyone is saying. I’ve always loved films that approach sound in an impressionistic way and that is an unusual approach for a mainstream blockbuster, but I feel it’s the right approach for this experiential film.”, https://www.indiewire.com/2020/09/tenet-sound-mixing-backlash-christopher-nolan-explained-1234583800/. Also, FWIW, I thought the 3rd season of Westworld was great. I am not one of those plot hole jerks, in other words. That was brilliant. So to counterbalance the awful mixing, I have to turn everything down as the action is too loud, and then yep, some dialog becomes hard to hear. No spoilers but the beginning (like many films, Bond for example) there's the setting up of plot and establishing the "mission" which requires a lot of explanation and exposition. One of the great joys of Inception is watching the heist guys interact with each other. It feels more farfetched than relatable. I'd love to talk with the sound crew who go to pains to get the best audio they can, only to have the director know in advance that it's going to get a blanket thrown over it. 8 Kat's Motivation I love the sheer hubris here of the implication that badly fucking up the sound mixing is in some way a sign of arthouse tendencies. Then as soon as he leaves you change the audio back to the audible dialogue. I watch all my films since Covid as I would in a movie theater...without subtitles. Moreover they assert that every Nolan's movie has problems with dialogues. The Protagonist: “Nah, I let him get ahold of the algorithm.”, The Protagonist: “How many sections of the algorithm does he [Sator] have?”. The sound designer, who didn't work on Tenet, went on to state that while dialogue can be difficult to understand because of the nature of the soundscape but … Possibly because you couldn't hear important dialogue, which is why we, like others, would suggest rewatching Tenet with subtitles. I haven't seen Tenet and probably won't because my only interest in it would be to see what all this fuss about the sound mix is all about - but honestly all this complaining about how hard it is to hear the dialogue and claims that it was an objectively bad creative choice seem pretty unimaginative to me. The sound in Nolan's films is bad and years from now he will regret it, surely. Really not a fan of the sound design. I’m puzzled. (After two viewings and hours poring over Reddit dissections, the best I can hazard on some of these questions is a well-informed guess.) I’m curious. But with sound mixing? Branaugh nailed that role in my view. If you have to turn up the volume to 50/100 to hear the dialog clearly, now the range can be from 0-50. Hands up if you’ve seen Tenet and thought it was intensely, no, make that maddeningly confusing? For me it was the vault host dialogue and the dialogue on the hydrofoil that was hard to hear. But with sound mixing? There’s really no other explanation other than terrible sound mixing. The Forbes review of Tenet … AMC Lincoln Sq, NYC, 3/5/21 11:30 am show. Even with subtitles on, the movie is "meh,ok" at best. That's fine. Largely due to how quick-witted/"perfect" the characters are. Write your own review for Tenet There are many moments in this film where viewers probably felt like they couldn't hear the dialogue, and then felt like they missed something important - and it's probably because the sound … I find Tenet's dialogues to be ok at worst and witty at best. The dialogue is mostly OK but you can't hear anything. Stuart Heritage. “Tenet has a sun cream squirt sound effect that is louder and clearer than some of its dialogue,” writes bemused Twitter User Luke Dunn. May I also hijack ever so slightly and ask a tangential question, that may or may not be easy to google...Why does Nolan insist on such bad sound design? In Tenet (2020) you can’t hear what the main characters are saying during important scenes because your friend Heath doesn’t know how to shut the fuck up. TBH, this is one of MANY examples where the dialogue mix is way too, even without music or sound effects are not featured prominently, such as Pro and Neil walking along the trolly and beginning to plot the heist or the 2nd walk and talk Pro has with Priya. That's a choice. Everyone is probably asking: what's the point of characters talking if viewers can't hear it? Press J to jump to the feed. I also really love time-travel movies in general, so I was expecting a lot. Basic example of how NOT TO make the stakes feel more personnal for the viewers, this is amateur level of writing, especially for Nolan. Zack Sharf. Er, hold on - which other types of movie? My point being, I am pretty well able to follow complicated plots, and I'm generally along for the ride even if the plot doesn't do everything it promises. It's ridiculous. The problem is that it's dramatically over-used in a lot of films these days. With that scene and those lines I was like, did Nolan take the day off that day or what? I’ve always loved films that approach sound in an impressionistic way and that is an unusual approach for a mainstream blockbuster, but I feel it’s the right approach for this experiential film. One need only point to the bewildered ex-cons in O Brother, Where Art Thou? The boffo global box office for “Tenet” is proof of the public appetite for Christopher Nolan’s abilities as a filmmaker, but as the film opens in more countries and, gradually, t… Fans have taken to Twitter to criticise the sound mix for Christopher Nolan’s Tenet, saying dialogue is almost incomprehensible. I think this was the only scene in the film where the over powering music was acceptable, because you didn’t really need the details as the picture zoomed to important elements from Neil’s POV. Sep 1, 2020 6:15 pm @zsharf. Which is why I am so puzzled by the choices made here, and even more, by Christopher Nolan's insistence that everything that the audience is having trouble with is intentional ... or they just didn't get the film. I paused it and rewound it, watch with subtitles, and was gobsmacked to realize that such an important scene with Sator and Pro showing their cards with respect to the botch job at the opera house was presented in a context that aggressively made it harder to understand the dialogue. We shouldn't have to go to film sites for clarification. Someone should remaster Tenet, badly. I've always taken minor issue with Nolan's dialogues. You don't want us to hear and understand what the actors are saying? It doesn't say anything to me about the story. It really doesn't add anything to the movie to make the dialogue hard to hear. Nolan's latest, Tenet, comes to 4K Blu-ray courtesy of Warner, with a native 4K presentation, expanded IMAX scenes, and a soundtrack where the dialogue is slightly more intelligible. When I die, the world dies with me, and your knowledge dies with you, buried in a tomb, like an anonymous Egyptian builder, sealed in a pyramid to keep his secret. But this way it's supposed to be art, because... the movie is ruined even further? “Clarity of story, clarity of emotions — I try to achieve that in a very layered way using all the different things at my disposal — picture and sound. Meanwhile, Forbes film writer Scott Mendelson tweeted, “For a movie that was supposed to ‘save’ cinemas, TENET would have been much more enjoyable with subtitles. “I don’t agree with the idea that you can only achieve clarity through dialogue,” Nolan continued. Your faith is blind. Overall, it has a pretty neutral sound profile that can reproduce vocals and dialogue clearly, though some upper harmonics can be a bit hard to hear. In the theater I could hear most of the Freeport tour and at home, the foreshadowing details of the heist plan were completely buried in the mix. I figured I'd be left thinking about it, but wasn't at all. Gorgeous visuals and game performances can’t compensate for generic action, thin characters and a needlessly convoluted plot. He has said in an interview the following: “I don’t agree with the idea that you can only achieve clarity through dialogue,” Nolan continued. Share This Article Reddit ... can hear … Warner has provided Tenet with an excellent DTS-HD MA 5.1 track that is a victim of its source material. Why he does it in a movie that relies soooo much on exposition in almost every scene is beyond me. Tenet is not an easy movie to understand. Late, but the one time I've seen low-volume/drowned-out dialogue actually have an "impressionistic" effect is that nightclub scene in The Social Network with Justin Timberlake. Tbh, Sator has some of my favorite lines in the movie. I just found the movie to be 'meh' overall. This isn't exactly a plot point of the movie, but it's definitely something that just literally makes no sense - and often doesn't when it comes to Christopher Nolan's chaotic and bold action scenes.. It’s almost as if Terrance Malick went sci-fi. Without realizing it, I glanced down at the bottom of the screen to look for subtitles. I’m still not sure how I feel about Nolan. There are timeline twists, back-stabs, and more than a few paradoxes. I was rooting for this film -- I was really looking forward to it. A movie should stand on its own. Read the review. I haven't seen Tenet because I don't really care for his films, but the exact reason I don't care for his films is because his side characters are walking exposition dispensers instead of...well, characters. Tenet: If you need to explain yourself when people complain that they can't hear the dialogue, you've failed I was rooting for this film -- I was really looking forward to it. Some believe that Tenet's dialogue gets drowned out by surrounding sound design and the score. Plenty of great films were misunderstood by audiences and critics alike upon release, which is not to say Tenet is a great film, but that an open mind is a virtue. Then I realized I’d rather be watching Neil scope the vault instead of hearing about vault security from the host. His recent films—Song to Song, Knight of Cups—are just moody vignettes of looks and sights and ambient laughter and sighing. How is it 'weird'? NATURE! Do the Coens overexplain everything? Possibly because you couldn’t hear important dialogue, which is why we, like others, would suggest rewatching Tenet with subtitles. Many a … What is really unique about the sound flaws in Tenet is how... just, unprofessional it is. In a Reddit AMA last year, ... 'Tenet', however, is a complex story to begin with. Read more. The sound design choices are seriously mind-boggling. For contrast, I thought the sound work in Portrait of a Lady on Fire was particularly successful in doing what Nolan said he's trying to do here (creating mood through sound design over dialogue, obviously there was no major drowning out of dialogue that I can remember in PoaLoF). I watched with subtitles and didn't have a problem. The dialog was mixed too … Tenet’s production notes describe how IMAX 70mm cameras are noisier than regular cameras. I feel every Kats dialog that mentios Max is supposed to make it more significant how much she hates her husband when she loses it and shoots him prematurely in the end, like she hates him so much she goes, eh, fuck it, im out, sorry universe ( and Max), but all it really did is made her come across as not only one dimensional but also illogical. I've never thought of Nolan as lazy -I mean just look at his level of output- but the muffled dialogue thing is baffilingly lazy. If dialog is loud and clear at 10/100, then the loudest sound can only ever be "10". That was the only scene that I remember not being able to hear dialogue (when you clearly are expected to, i.e. He says it's "an unusual approach for a mainstream blockbuster", implying that it's a usual approach in other types of movie. “Tenet has a sun cream squirt sound effect that is louder and clearer than some of its dialogue,” writes bemused Twitter User Luke Dunn. (If you have yet to see it, consider this story a … I'd say that Sator is way too smart. Watching this in the theater a few times and then at home yielded two wildly different experiences for me. There are many moments in this film where viewers probably felt like they couldn't hear the dialogue, and then felt like they missed something important - and it's probably because the sound was too loud, and the dialogue too quiet. Because it is crystal fucking clear, and even when it isn't, you get that it's supposed to be muddled. I still don’t like how TP delivers the line, “the collapse of the Soviet Union.”. There's plenty of other lines I love (from Sator as well as others), but those are just a few of my favorites from him. She says this quote to him, and it is one of many that can be seen as Nolan talking to the audience. Why?". It has been rather well-documented online about how many who saw the film theatrically had a hard time hearing the dialogue in the film, yet Nolan has insisted it is all intentional as part of the “sonic experience.” This was clearly intentional....BUT everything else is muddled.

How To Make A Map Responsive, Chelsea Fc Magazine Membership, South Dakota State University Graduation 2020, Altered 2006 Trailer, What Is Updating Chart, Presto Create Index,